A Performance Comparison of Data Dissemination Protocols for Wireless Sensor Networks

Tatiana Bokareva, Nirupama Bulusu and Sanjay Jha

Abstract

In recent years a variety of new data dissemination protocols have been develeoped specifically for wireless sensor networks (WSN), but no realistic performance comparison between them has been attempted. This paper reports on the results of a simulation comparison made by an independent researcher using the ns-2.26 simulator for the WSN protocols: Directed Diffusion (DD), Two-Tier Data Dissemination (TTDD) and Gradient Broadcast (GRAB).

Our performance study provides useful insights for the network designer --- such as which protocols (and design choices) scale control traffic well, improve data delivery or reduce overall energy consumption. We observe that despite the designers intentions to make these protocols self-configuring, they in fact rely on a number of statically configured parameters which are the cause of the reduction in performance. For example, the static preconfiguration of cell size in TTDD is one of the reasons why TTDD exhibits larger routing overhead than DD by 67.6% on average. Although GRAB produces approximately 93.6% smaller overhead than TTDD and 89.27% smaller than DD, because of statically configured credit amount, GRAB delivers on average 6 times more redundant data packets than TTDD and DD. We suggest that making these protocols truly self-learning can significantly improve their performance, and comment on how some of the parameters can be dynamically derived through measurements of network and event dynamics.

Availability

This paper is available in PDF format.

Reference

Bokareva04a Tatiana Bokareva, Nirupama Bulusu and Sanjay Jha. A Performance Comparison of Data Dissemination Protocols for Wireless Sensor Networks. In Proceedings of IEEE Globecom Wireless Ad Hoc and Sensor Networks Workshop, Dallas, Texas, USA. November, 2004. .

@article{Bokareva04a,
author = "Tatiana Bokareva and Nirupama Bulusu and Sanjay Jha",
title = "A Performance Comparison of Data Dissemination Protocols for Wireless Sensor Networks",
journal = "In Proceedings of IEEE Globecom Wireless Ad Hoc and Sensor Networks Workshop",
volume = "",
number = "",
year = "2004",
publisher = "IEEE Communications Society,"
month = "November",
pages = "",
keywords = "performance comparison; data dissemination; wireless sensor networks",
}

Copyright

This paper is copyright © 2004 by its authors. Permission to make digital or hard copies of part or all of this work for personal use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that new copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. Abstracting with credit is permitted. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission of the authors.